Scott McTominay Could Be Everton’s Midfield Fix This January

Everton‘s plans for the winter window are starting to look more focused, and the player at the center of it all is Scott McTominay. The club has been linked with plenty of midfielders over the past year, yet the tone around this one feels different. Reports say Everton are preparing a significant offer to lure the midfielder away from Napoli, and the conversation inside the fanbase has quickly shifted from curiosity to expectation.

Multiple reports claim Everton are looking at this deal as a priority for January. Some say the club is ready to move early, believing McTominay gives the team a mix of experience, physicality, and direct play that can change the rhythm of their midfield. Other sources add that the fee could be high, though Everton believe the investment is justified. The picture is changing fast, and the club’s interest looks serious.

Why Everton See McTominay as an Immediate Upgrade

Everton’s reasoning is straightforward. McTominay knows Premier League tempo, reads danger well and rarely hides in physical games. His style fits the current coaching approach, which values direct play, quick transitions and midfielders who can cover space without losing discipline.

At Manchester United he filled different roles depending on the manager. At Napoli he adapted again, working in a more technical league while still offering his trademark intensity. Everton view this versatility as a major plus. The squad has lacked players who can shift between defensive and forward-moving duties without losing control of the midfield shape.

Leadership also matters. The team has gone through so many changes that calming voices have become valuable. McTominay has shown he can influence teammates through presence and confidence, something Everton feel the current group needs.

All of this explains why the club have placed him near the top of their January priorities. It is rare to find someone with both top-flight experience and a game built around consistency rather than unpredictability.

Napoli’s Role in How the Deal Unfolds

Napoli’s stance remains the biggest obstacle. They have relied on McTominay during a period of injuries and heavy fixture congestion. The club want to keep the group intact at least until the summer. That means Everton will need a strong offer just to begin a real discussion.

Numbers around the deal vary from source to source, though most agree it will take a significant fee to make Napoli pause. Everton understand this and are prepared for a negotiation that may move slowly. They also know Napoli’s decision becomes easier only if the player shows interest in returning to England.

What makes this situation tricky is timing. Napoli do not want to weaken their midfield during a stretch of difficult matches, and McTominay has been one of their most stable performers. Everton cannot rely solely on financial leverage. They need alignment from the player, and so far there has been no clear signal from his side.

For now Everton are evaluating different structures and waiting for Napoli to indicate whether a January discussion is realistic.

Why His Scotland Performances Matter

McTominay’s performance for Scotland against Denmark has given Everton even more confidence. He was praised for his positioning and decision making, with observers noting how he helped control key moments in the match. Everton view this as proof he performs well when instructions are clear and responsibilities are defined.

The club also believe his international form reflects a player who responds well to pressure. Scotland rely on him in big games, and that reliability is something Everton value. The team have struggled with consistency in midfield, especially in matches where rhythm shifts quickly. McTominay offers a steadier presence and tends to raise his level when the game becomes unpredictable.

This is why fans have started discussing not just whether Everton should sign him but how he would fit into the starting eleven. When supporters begin imagining tactical setups around a player, it usually means the link has moved beyond speculation.

The Deal Is Not Set in Stone

Even with momentum building, Everton still have work to do. They need clarity on Napoli’s position, they need the player to show interest, and they need to prepare an offer that makes sense financially. January windows often move in sudden jumps, and Everton want to be ready for any opportunity.

Inside the club the message is to stay patient. Staff members are preparing scenarios, gathering updates and keeping communication channels open. They know this window is important and want to avoid choices that create problems later in the season.

Everton believe McTominay fits the direction they want to take. The question is whether the timing aligns. If the player signals he is open to a move and Napoli soften their stance, this could become one of the defining transfer stories of the winter.